"Mayfield is both excellent and bad because he can only play at one tempo," said former QB coach Seth Galina of Pro Football Focus. "That explains why there's so much inconsistency." Baker's fastball is as excellent as anybody in the game, but occasionally you need a second pitch, which Baker lacks. That's where his slow ball and changeup come into play.
He has an arm like a pitcher, with a strong, long throwing arm and solid accuracy from all over the field. He also shows some touch when he needs to throw across his body to get out hitters. But most important, he has a big heart and wants to win so badly that it comes through in everything he does on the field. In other words, he's a winner.
However, there are times when he appears confused with what's going on around him and makes some errant throws. This can be attributed to him being a first-year player in an advanced offense that uses a lot of pre-snap motions. If he gets overwhelmed, it could end up hurting the team. But if he stays focused, he should improve as he gains more experience.
Overall, it's safe to say that Mayfield is an above-average quarterback who has the potential to be great. He has the size, arm strength, and intelligence required to be a starting quarterback in the NFL.
Why Baker Mayfield Will Not Fail It is far too soon to compare his NFL career to that of other former quarterbacks. However, there is compelling evidence that he is the ideal quarterback for the Cleveland Browns. In fact, some experts believe he could be the best quarterback in the franchise's history.
Mayfield has all the physical tools you look for in an NFL quarterback: size, arm strength, mobility, and mental aptitude. He also has the personality traits you want in a leader: charisma, confidence, and competitiveness. But can he play well enough to avoid being labeled a bust? The answer is no; Mayfield will not fail.
Mayfield was drafted first overall by the Browns because they believed he was the best quarterback available. General manager John Dorsey said after making the selection that Mayfield was "a perfect fit" for their offense. This statement indicates that Dorsey and the rest of the team's management knew exactly what kind of player they were selecting with the No. 1 pick.
Browns head coach Gregg Williams called Mayfield "the most competitive guy I've ever been around." This shows that the team knew what they were getting when they chose him over players such as Sam Darnold, Josh Allen, and Josh Rosen.
Baker Mayfield has been performing well in recent weeks. Though the Cleveland Browns lost to the Baltimore Ravens on Monday night, it wasn't for a lack of effort from Mayfield, who had 343 passing yards and three total touchdowns to help Cleveland put 42 points on the Baltimore defense. It was the first time this season that Mayfield has thrown for over 300 yards.
Mayfield's previous high was 309 yards, which he threw for against the Pittsburgh Steelers in Week 9. He also had three touchdown passes in that game. Overall, Mayfield is averaging 282.3 yards per game after nine games this season.
The number one reason why Mayfield has been so effective this year is because of his ability as a runner. He has 515 rushing yards this season, which is second only to San Francisco 49ers' quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo (who has 518). In addition, Mayfield has five touchdowns on the ground, which is second only to Denver Broncos' quarterback Joe Flacco (seven).
Mayfield entered the NFL as a rookie when Derek Carr led the Browns to a 38-28 win over the Baltimore Ravens. Through nine games this season, Mayfield has already surpassed both his career high in interceptions with 13 and his total yardage mark (4,920) set last season.
Overall, Mayfield is having a stellar start to his first season as a full-time starter.
In two games, he was 44/71 (61.9 percent), 467 yards, four touchdowns, and one interception. Josh Allen: 77/120 (64.1%), 817 yards, 5 touchdowns, 1 interception in three games. Faced a 15th-ranked pass defense on average, but Allen had more success because he stayed in the game longer.
Mayfield's numbers are inflated by two games that were lost to injury. He missed most of 2017 with a shoulder injury and then played just three quarters last year before tearing his ACL. He's been fantastic this year without even practicing during the offseason.
However, it's difficult to compare quarterbacks who never played together before 2018. They have different supporting casts, are coming from different systems, and have different work ethics. Mayfield is a gunslinger who likes to throw early while Allen is more of a sitter back and wait type player. Mayfield has also shown he can take over games while Allen tends to get dominated by stronger defenses.
Ultimately, these are two very different players who play very similar positions. Mayfield is an athletic quarterback who makes good decisions with the ball and has shown he can lead teams on the field. Allen is a strong-armed quarterback who needs time to develop into a leader. Both have their strengths and weaknesses, but it's clear they will be important parts of their respective offenses for years to come.
Baker Mayfield went from being a walk-on at Texas Tech to winning the Heisman Trophy at Oklahoma and becoming the first overall choice in the NFL draft. While his departure from Texas Tech was unexpected at the time, he now clarified that it was because of coach Kliff Kingsbury. Mayfield said during his Heisman acceptance speech that "someone has to be the face of the franchise" while pointing out that no Red Raiders were listed on the trophy's cover. He later signed with the Cleveland Browns as a rookie.
Kingsbury left Texas Tech after one season to become the head coach at Arizona State. He was replaced by Matt Wallerstedt, who had been the team's offensive coordinator.
Mayfield was drafted first overall by the Browns and will begin his career with them. He commented on his decision to turn down Texas Tech by saying "I think it's best for me to go where I can start right away."
Mayfield's success at Oklahoma was expected since he came into college football with a lot of hype. However, what wasn't expected was his immediate impact on the field when he started playing right away. He led the Sooners to an undefeated regular season before losing to Alabama in the College Football Playoff. After his freshman year, Mayfield announced that he would forgo his remaining years of eligibility and enter the 2018 NFL draft. He was also named the winner of the 2017 Heisman Trophy.